A recent case before Brazil’s Supreme Court, Tema 843, has sparked debate over the role of budgetary impact in shaping the court’s decisions on tax matters.
The case, RE 835.818, ruled on October 7, 2026, centers on the exclusion of presumed ICMS credits from the calculation base of Cofins and PIS contributions. The court’s decision, reported by Minister Marco Aurélio, found this inclusion incompatible with the Federal Constitution.
Budgetary Impact and Legal Modulation
The 2023 Budget Guidelines Law estimated a R$16.5 billion fiscal impact from this ruling, a figure unchanged in subsequent years. This highlights how budgetary considerations may influence the court’s modulation of legal effects.
Legal scholars Breno Vasconcelos, Tathiane Piscitelli, and Maria Raphaela Matthiesen argue that the Supreme Court should not rely solely on budgetary impact estimates. They emphasize the need for a consistent, in-depth analysis to justify using such arguments within legal frameworks.
Similarly, Piscitelli and Juliana Furtado Costa Araujo analyzed Supreme Court rulings where financial impacts influenced the modulation of effects. Their conclusion: generic use of budgetary arguments could undermine legal certainty and trust in the system.
In Tema 843, no request for modulation was filed by parties or amici curiae, allowing for an examination of budgetary information before any modulation decision. This contrasts with cases like Tema 69, where modulation was only established in 2021, years after the 2017 ruling.
The R$16.5 billion estimate, repeated since 2023 without updates or methodological changes, highlights the need for clarity. If budgetary impact is to be a factor, its calculation and implications must be thoroughly explained and legally justified.
Related Post: Ericsson loses case against AsusTek in court
The court faces a complex task in deciding whether to modulate the temporal effects in Tema 843.
The Role of Budgetary Impact in Legal Modulation
The case of Tema 69, which dealt with the exclusion of ICMS from the calculation base of PIS and COFINS, provides a relevant comparison. The merits of this case were judged in 2017, but the modulation was only established in 2021 during the declaratory appeals. Here, the budgetary impact predicted in the Budget Guidelines Law and supported by the National Treasury played a significant role in limiting the temporal framework set by the Supreme Court.
Tema 843 and the Need for Clarity
This consistency raises questions about the methodology and criteria used to calculate this figure. The Fiscal Risks Annex of the Budget Guidelines Law states that these estimates are provided by the Federal Revenue of Brazil (RFB) and represent the maximum impact on the treasury, which may or may not materialize.
If the estimated fiscal impact represents the maximum impact, how does this align with the actual expected consequences of the judgment? What is the degree of certainty involved, and what methodology was used? These questions show the need for transparency and detailed justification when using budgetary impact arguments in legal modulation.
The absence of any request for modulation of effects by the parties or amici curiae in RE 835.818 allows for an examination of budgetary information before any modulation decision.
In late October 2026, the Supreme Court concluded the judgment of Tema 118, which deals with the exclusion of ISS from the calculation base of PIS and COFINS. This case also involves a significant budgetary impact.

