Law, One Gateway

Court upholds Align patent against Angelalign

Published on 16/11/2026 • By Shakira Osman

A ruling from the Unified Patent Court’s Paris division has determined that Align Technology’s patent on orthodontic appliances with specific cavity designs is valid and that Angelalign Technology’s competing clear aligner systems violate those claims. The decision prohibits Angelalign from selling its Angel Aligner Select and Pro products—equipped with the AngelAttach system’s Torque Ridge—within the UPC’s jurisdiction.

The patented technology, identified as EP 2 237 738, describes an orthodontic device featuring a single, uninterrupted ridge designed to produce precise tooth movement, particularly third-order root adjustments involving lingual torque. Align contended that Angelalign’s products replicated this innovation, prompting the legal action filed in August 2025 against Angelalign and four European subsidiaries.

Key Disputes Over Patent Interpretation

The central conflict revolved around whether the phrase “buccal side of the cavity” in the patent claims exclusively applied to cavities for posterior teeth or extended to any outer cavity surface. The court interpreted “buccal” as equivalent to “facial,” thereby broadening the patent’s scope to include anterior teeth. This interpretation was critical, as Angelalign’s Torque Ridge is applied to front teeth, directly aligning with the patent’s protected design.

Angelalign’s arguments, challenging the patent for added matter regarding the ridge’s “single” and “continuous” attributes, as well as inventive step based on prior art combinations, were rejected. The judges determined that a person skilled in the field would not have logically merged the referenced documents to arrive at the claimed solution without the benefit of hindsight.

While Align secured an injunction across 17 UPC member states, the court dismissed claims against three Angelalign entities for alleged UK-based infringements. The panel ruled that Align had not adequately demonstrated the applicable UK legal framework in its initial filings, and subsequent submissions failed to remedy the deficiency by merely citing UPC procedural rules.

Judicial Outcomes and Industry Impact

The panel ordered an injunction in 17 UPC countries, including recall and destruction of infringing products, with penalty payments of up to €10,000 per infringing product or €20,000 per day of continuous infringement. Financial compensation for damages begins from the patent‘s grant date of July 12, 2023.

Related Post: ZTE, Samsung Settle Global Patent Dispute Over 4G, 5G Tech

This decision follows a pattern of UPC disputes between the two companies. In February 2026, the Düsseldorf division issued a preliminary injunction under EP 4 346 690, covering software for dynamic orthodontic treatment adjustments. An appellate court later upheld that injunction after confirming Angelalign’s iOrtho software’s “Live Now” feature infringed the claims. However, in May 2026, Düsseldorf rejected another preliminary injunction request by Align, this time over EP 4 295 806, which pertains to aligner designs for extraction cases, citing insufficient evidence of infringement.

A full merits hearing on EP 690, including Angelalign’s counterclaim to invalidate the patent, remains pending in Düsseldorf. Separate legal battles over equivalent patents are also underway in the United States and China. Additionally, Align has initiated revocation proceedings against three of Angelalign’s patents.

Align was represented in the Paris proceedings by the UK mixed firm Carpmaels & Ransford, led by partner and patent attorney John Brunner together with litigation partner Agathe Michel-de-Cazotte. The team included associates Ben Chapman, Caroline Horstmann, Will Mooney, Salomé Nattagh and Daisy Makin.

Düsseldorf-based IP boutique Arnold Ruess acted for the five Angelalign entities, with partner Arno Risse and counsel Tim Smentkowski in the lead, assisted by associate Tugce Altun. Arnold Ruess also represents Angelalign in the parallel UPC proceedings in Düsseldorf, working with patent attorneys Dirk Schulz, Ulrich Storz and Wanze Zhang from Michalski Hüttermann & Partner.

With litigation ongoing in multiple jurisdictions, industry observers will monitor how this decision affects pending cases, including the Düsseldorf merits trial and cross-border proceedings. The case reference is UPC_CFI_684/2025, with the ruling issued by a panel comprising Camille Lignières (presiding judge), Carine Gillet (judge-rapporteur), Marjolein Visser (legally qualified judge), and Elisabetta Papa (technically qualified judge).

SHARE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *